Giving Up Power to Gurus
Something rather ironic occurred to me recently. After the Ideagasms fiasco, after seeing more and more guru's as fakes—like what "The Game" did with TylerDurden. I started to objectively think and observe how Guru's really are. I started to notice the some of the more successful Pick Up Guru's are guys with amazing flash game—they can do a 15-minute song and dance, or "wing" you very well, but they talk very little about true seduction.
In fact, I noticed about 90% of the dating community is about opening and being flashy, maybe 8% is on building comfort with a girl you just met and taking her on a first date. Then about 1% is on actual relationships and the other 1% is on real seduction and making women feel beautiful, wanted, and pleasured.
I went to my local lair's meeting the other day and realized how deep this goes. Lately I have been distancing myself from any flash-guru, or any sage advice and I noticed lots of guys in my lair really dig what gurus have to say. It's like they built their whole lives around it. It's not everyone and ironically, some of the guys who are most guru minded are getting some success. So it's a tough cookie here…
I am guilty of it too. There are things in my life that I got from the community that probably will never change, like the bad taste in my mouth when I pay for a girl's dinner. One time, I hooked up with a girl really fast, like within a couple hours, and afterwards I remember Mystery saying "getting laid fast is Fool's Mate, just like a bad chess player thinking they are good because they win in 3 moves." Man, what horrible advice by Guru Mystery…
Anyway, I started to realize from my life, from people I know in the dating community, that we give away way too much power to these Gurus. The ironic part is, they teach not to give away power to girls or anyone else, but what I notice almost without exception is guys who are deep into this shit look up to Guru's like they are gods. When they do get a success, it almost seems like that attribute it to their teacher and not themselves.
Another rather unfortunately aspect of the community is guys who aren't at Guru level, but could otherwise give good advice at things like breaking-the-ice, staying in a positive state, or basic social etiquette are pinned a Keyboard Jockey (KJ) if they chime in. I know, I fell into that and called people a KJ when they gave advice without proof & warranty. In fact, I have been called a KJ by some because I love to write but am not a guru. It's ironic that I will blog about most of my lays but I take them down for privacy. So, unless you have status in the community, giving advice is shunned on.
That creates a perfect breeding ground for Gurus. If you can gain status (usually all you need is consistent flash game and only a few lays), you can be a guru. Just look around.
I don't doubt there are excellent guys out there. But we really created a system where community guys of high status are almost worshipped and guys just give their power away to them. Thinking back to ideagasms, there were guys who would take their girlfriends to see Stephane, and soon you'd hear stories about how the girl soon left that guy. In fact, that is exactly how Stephane got Amy Jo and Greta. He took them from old students. My guess is Amy and Greta saw how their boyfriends gave their power away to Guru Steph and the girls lost their attraction.
So, I consider myself out of the guru-community. I love women and will date them for many more years and use lots of guru ideas, but I feel I am done taking sage advice. I only take advice from my close friends when I ask or if I am specifically looking up some information. More on this later.
As an aside, after 4 years of this stuff, my style of picking up women mostly revolves around finding a girl who already is attracted to me naturally, breaking the ice with her (unless she approaches me), try to befriends her group if they are there, and keep strong eye contact with intense focus on her, touch her when appropriate, and steal a kiss the second I can. From there, if I can isolate her, I'll try to get intimate and let nature take it from there.
This breaks lots of community rules and means I am not very consistent—but my interactions are fucking awesome. Although I did adopt a lot of these ideas from the community, I had to sift through a lot. But from the get-go, I am not just approaching every girl in every moment; I wait till I sense natural signals from women. As long as I am listening, I tend to notice.
So, a guru may come around and say you can stay fat, poor, and just learn these simple steps and you will be great. And since the guru is already pretty darn good at socializing, making friends, and being flashy, they'll easily win you over. Of course, guru's can help you, for sure. Don't get me wrong, my main point here is Use The Community; Don't Be Used By It.
I realize this blog sounds challenging. I realize it may insult lots of people. But I ask you, try to think about your guru of choice, think about your day-to-day life and how reasonably you could fit their cookie-cutter ideas into your life?
So how do you find what works for you? Well, I think the best step you can take is to find friends with similar goals. This may take a little time and I do suggest meeting women as you do it, but try to find guys who are already good with women and be their friend. Open up to them, and if they choose to be your friend too, perfect. The guy doesn't have to be a master pick up artist. He can be some ex-frat guy who dated a dozen women in school or it could be an ex-football player who got laid a lot in school. Anything like that. This is one of my main goals now, second to actually meeting women.
As you guys get to know each other, he'll be able to give you some solid advice about what could work for you. If what they say sounds true to you, sweet. But if the advice sounds overly harsh or overly simple, then keep looking for friends who are good with women, trust me they are out there. Finding great friends should be a continuous process for you. You can only gain.
A friend and mentor can help give you more tailored advice to your life. This is how it worked with me and SDH. My dating life is awesome now and the people I get to know in real life understand me better.
Unfortunately, I can't seem to get these ideas across to my community friends. One guy called me out on being a KJ for saying this stuff. That kinda pissed me off considering I met my current girl while I was with him.
But I know what I am saying is pretty radical for the community and so I choose to separate myself a little from the guruy-sagey aspects of it.
In my experiences, only people who actually spend the time to get to know you, actually care about you personally, actually want you to succeed… they are the ones who are qualified to give you advice and it doesn't matter if they are a guru or not. Think back to your old childhood friends who gave you advice in various things like sports, video games, or school work. Why is advice different when it comes to topics of women and dating? Before the community, most guys keep very quiet about dating and feel it's un-cool to even ask for advice, now we enter the community and look up to Sage Gurus, but now we think back to our old good friends who know us real well and maybe think "Hey, let me ask my close friends for advice. They knows me, may know what could work for me, maybe they have some decent ideas."
So, don't give your power away to anyone except those you carefully choose, if even that. Personally, I choose to give my power away to my career and yeah, if my career were to just tumble and plummet, I'd feel horrible. But at least I have some control over it.
Lastly, really try to notice if you are giving your power away to gurus. Do you take their advice almost without question? Do you get mad if someone contradicts them and want to argue? Do you refuse help from anyone else but the Guru?
I should write a follow up post on Quality Control and how to filter advice. I don't intend to mean "take advice from anyone, even a 13 year old," what I mean is learn to construct advice-filters in your mind so you can hear stuff from anyone, even a Guru or someone young, and pick-and-choose what sounds true to you.
Doesn't what I am saying feel right? The idea of tailored advice for you personally? Me establishing that relationship with SDH has changed my life. Things are progressing in the most healthy way in years. If you have questions, feel free to comment.
UPDATE
After some great comment questions, I wanted to add this footer to clarify some points (its from the comments below):
Well, first off I probably should have proof read that blog post a few more times before unleashing it. I didn't mean to convey that you get your actual dating advice from AFC's...
What I meant was creating a filter for yourself to take out the junk in the advice you hear and focus on the meat.
So, say a guru is trying to tell you to live a Circle LifeStyle (2+ girlfriends), and he tells you about all the amazing sex, about all the spiritual development, about all the admiration you will get. But at the end of the day, no one really pulls it off and people end up messing their current relationship. It seems like more trouble than its worth.
On the contrary, say an AFC friend gives you terrible advice like "buy all women drinks and ask them for a date".
We got to be able to filter both out, no matter whom it comes form. More often that advice is from a Guru since their voice is easier heard. But don't just discount your regular friends advice because they are AFC's. Even if 80% of what they say is trash, there could be little gems in there very tailored to you because they know you very well already, more than any guru. You got to find those gems while on your life path, trust me.
In the end, what I am saying is not getting sucked into some Guru's (or anyone's) reality. Take the advice form the Guru that you think will work for you, try it out, and drop the rest.
Thanks for asking these questions guys, this post was pretty hard to write and I wasn't sure if my point really got accross right. I may tack this on to the end of that blog post.
SDH goes into a lot more depth in his follow up post here. I definitely think that should be read too.


These "Gurus" are mostly incomplete men
I'm sitting here watching the beginning of Hypnotica's "Deep Phone Seduction" and he's being interviewed by this twerp who is up on all the lingo but clearly doesn't have any presence or a clue about how to just live an awesome life. Hypnotica had to ask him six or seven times why he was doing this to get an honest answer, which finally occurred when the twerp shrugged his shoulders and said weakly "for sex?"
Is that guy a "guru??" I think most AFCs have more going for them than he does!
Mehow is no better. The first time I saw him was as a student in Hypnotica's DVD "Deep Inner Game," and I just thought he was an AFC goofball who needed help on his game. Turns out he's an AFC goofball alright, but he's making a ton of money selling mediocre techniques to the general public.
Hypnotica himself is a freakshow. His stuff is pretty awesome, but I have *zero* interest in "being Hypnotica" or living his lifestyle. Ditto for Steve P. I see these guys as therapists, not role models. I somehow doubt they'd be the least bit offended by my saying this, either.
I'm with you on this one. I got into this because I remember the "cool guys" in high school and college and I wanted to build myself up so I too could be one of those guys with an awesome lifestyle. There has to come a point where you look around and say "I'm here," put down the books and just enjoy your life. For me, I think I'll get there faster hanging around "regular guys" who live that life that I want than following "gurus" whose lives, for the most part, are far more screwed up than mine, but who happen to know some cool techniques for meeting women.
http://thespgdiaries.blogspot.com
advice from friends isn't very useful in my experience
What you say about gurus is true and a lot of them are really just trying to make a buck or inflate their own egos. However, I find that getting advice from friends regarding women is pretty useless. At least with my friends, the women advice I get from them is banal, uninsightful, and oftentimes downright wrong when acted upon in the field. Even my one natural friend's advice is unactionable because it so full of mystically mumbojumbo. I find that the community idea that advice from naturals is offbase and advice from afc's wrong to be completely true in my experience.
I have to agree with this as
I have to agree with this as well. My friends can only get weirdos or fat chicks. Or women who simply have too much baggage. My best friend, who always got laid the most, pretty much gave up women because the quality wasn't there. So I've got no one but 'gurus' to go to for advice.
I totally agree, but I really meant...
Well, first off I probably should have proof read that blog post a few more times before unleashing it. I didn't mean to convey that you get your actual dating advice from AFC's...
What I meant was creating a filter for yourself to take out the junk in the advice you hear and focus on the meat.
So, say a guru is trying to tell you to live a Circle LifeStyle (2+ girlfriends), and he tells you about all the amazing sex, about all the spiritual development, about all the admiration you will get. But at the end of the day, no one really pulls it off and people end up messing their current relationship. It seems like more trouble than its worth.
On the contrary, say an AFC friend gives you terrible advice like "buy all women drinks and ask them for a date".
We got to be able to filter both out, no matter whom it comes form. More often that advice is from a Guru since their voice is easier heard. But don't just discount your regular friends advice because they are AFC's. Even if 80% of what they say is trash, there could be little gems in there very tailored to you because they know you very well already, more than any guru. You got to find those gems while on your life path, trust me.
In the end, what I am saying is not getting sucked into some Guru's (or anyone's) reality. Take the advice form the Guru that you think will work for you, try it out, and drop the rest.
Thanks for asking these questions guys, this post was pretty hard to write and I wasn't sure if my point really got accross right. I may tack this on to the end of that blog post.
SDH goes into a lot more
SDH goes into a lot more depth in his follow up post here. I definitely think that should be read too.
I totally agree with you,
I totally agree with you, Bigsend. For me, Ideagasms was mainly cool for the drama and interesting people I could meet, initially, until Steph started kicking those people off. I never could get into Ross Jeffries too much--other than the fact that I thought he was very funny--because he seemed to have too much of that flash. But, anyway, I've been looking into products by people who don't seem to want to be gurus at all--like Mr. Fuentes' Sexual Key stuff. And I'm looking into a product called Dating 2 Relating. But then, you never know how good these people's products are without any outside advice. And the products that get reviewed are those from the established "flashy" gurus. So the training a would-be seducer gets is pretty lopsided by those who are simply the better marketers.
I think one thing to look for is: Does this person have a pretty complete product or does he have a product line? How complete is each product in that product line? And how well does the person answer all your questions when asked them? At least those questions are a start.
I also agree that someone trying to make you into a cookie cutter image of themselves is b.s. But that's what a lot of gurus seem to want you to be. Another criteria should be "how well does this product allow me to expand the person I already am?"
Btw, I just got an email from Steph saying he has a new product coming out. I can't wait to see what the ex-IG groups has to say about that.
perspective from a girl
Speaking as a girl, I agree with you completely about guys not developing the deeper parts of game. I get approached a lot by guys who are doing routines and openers but when you dig even just slightly below that, there is nothing there.
If you're interested in a seduction experience that feels amazingly good from a girl's perspective, I blogged about my recent one:
http://awakeningfromthedream.blogspot.com/2008/10/natural-game-part-ii-h...
Don't get me wrong -- I love the seduction/PUA community because it's raising consciousness. I want to live in a world where men and women are having fun and are win/win about their interactions. I welcome your feedback about how we can move toward that kind of a world.
Excellent points
Brad P. published on Cliff's List some pretty interesting original research recently about that exact issue: how much of yourself should you invest in learning about seduction from the community, and how should you integrate it ? Do gurus play any part, and if so, which ? It's a bit of a read, and is certainly controversial, but I think it really complements what has been posted here.
To me when you are a cool
To me when you are a cool guy- trustworthy, in consider of other feelings, strong, honest, loyal, confident, know what you want and who you are-
Pick Up is a joke.
Why do you want to befriend her friends? If you're a cool guy and they don't like you and the girl isn't mature enough to handle it- SCREW HER. Who needs a girlfriend like that? Do you need anyones approval if you are allowed to date that girl? Hell NO! They better respect you for what you are or leave you for good.
Why do you focus on HER? Why don't you focus on YOURSELF? If you are yourself and she isn't attracted to that- SCREW HER. Why chase somebody who doesn't like who you truely are? Why do you compromise yourself to her values? Why are you so busy thinking what she thinks about you? How you make her like you?
What's wrong with doing something inappropriate? When you want to kiss her and she's not ready yet, what's the big deal? Stop being ashamed of wanting to kiss a girl man! If she's cool and you like her and she likes you it's fucking normal to go for a kiss! Man you don't assault her or stuff- It's a kiss! Just go like 'It's Ok if you don't want to kiss now, I respect that. we can kiss later when you feel comfortable.'
If she doesn't want to KISS but spends that much time chatting with you and allowing you to touch her SCREW HER. We don't need manipulativ validation seeking girlfriends! She's playing games with your feelings.
Just the way you write - 'steal a kiss' - Man kissing is beautiful! Being intimate with someone is beautiful. And natural. It is hardly something she will regret if she knows what's good for her. It is a good thing you know^^
See that's the reason why you need that Pick Up stuff. Go for it and learn your lesson, but think about your attitude towards women.
You are not any less then they are and your feelings and wants are more important than what she or someone else thinks of you.
As long as you are honest to yourself and to her you can pretty much do anything. I don't blame you and if someone does- SCREW HIM^^
I can totally see why you don't trust ideagasms anymore. You still have the Pick Up mentality. Ideagasms is the opposite of Pick Up. There is no way to do Pick Up in a heart centered way. Because you lie to yourself when you think of her being more important than you.
Pick Up is mind control -> Making somebody like you. Try to 'get' girls.
Ideagasms heart to heart -> Connecting with people without taking shit. See if girls can handle it.
Hey Steph...
I got this odd feeling that comment was written by Stephane... something about the writing style.
I'm not really sure how to respond to that.
One thing I can't stand about that guru-ish philosophy
"You need to be enlightened and have no feelings of shame, guilt, or negativity and then you can enjoy women and life! duhh" -Guru.
I feel like all that does is make people feel guilty for feeling guilty.
Makes people feel ashamed for feeling ashamed.
Its a big circle.
Guys, take a close look at that comment above. What can you actually do with that advice?
It is so vague, yet so pointed.
Man I'm not Steph, I'm just
Man I'm not Steph, I'm just (still) into IG. Hope that is not a problem. And Calibration is something I ignore.
Where have you read the word enlightened in my post?
I said you don't need to feel ashamed of... No shoulds anywhere. Just questions to ask yourself. read it again.
The problem is: What do you do when you feel negative emotions? Like your example shame. What do you do?
Deny it and act as if you wouldn't feel it?
Beat yourself up 'you shouldn't feel like that'?
Emotions are there for a reason. You were tought not to feel bad, don't cry, don't feel sad, don't be angry. You shouldn't feel that way. It's not good for you. When the opposite is true.
Go and feel bad. FEEL it. The more you go into the feeling the better. When approach anxiety kicks in go for it! Feel it as strong as you can! Feel it for days if you can! Recall memories and feel it again. What will happen you get used to it and it will lose it's impact. Like doing cold showers. You will still feel it but it will go through you and out quick.
I know I use some Ideagasms language but I like it. And I can explain things with my OWN view, no need for praising enlightenment or putting someone above the other one.
And I'm not there also. I often feel like shit. I just startet this feel stuff and it's a long way to go.
I like to repeat this one:
You are not any less then they are and your feelings and wants are more important than what she or someone else thinks of you.
Thats the mindset I go for with the last post. No inferior/superior or anything. Just that.
It's Steph. The post reads
It's Steph. The post reads just like his stuff--only with a more "burnt out on drugs" vibe to it. He's still trying to talk like a guru.
I'm not Steph man. And drugs
I'm not Steph man. And drugs are bad my friend ;D
Great example of BigSend's point...
Read this and see the danger of Guru worship.
Is there an original thought in that ramble?
Or is it regurgitated nonsense?
Is any of that based on life experience? Or just silliness?
Thanks for commenting!
Wher's the point?
Talk about manipulation, lets take your post sdh:
> Read this and see the danger of Guru worship.
What is dangerous in my post? You accusing me without any proof. THATS manipulation. I belive in Ideagasms, I don't belive in calibration. And I say what I think about Pick Up and Ideagasms.
> Is there an original thought in that ramble?
This is not even a question, you claim I don't have original thoughts and that I ramble. My opinion resonates a lot with the philosophy behind Ideagasms. Does that make it less valuable? SHOW me what point is unclear.
> Or is it regurgitated nonsense?
Ok SHOW me the nonsense. Point at what disturbes you. You are very insulting to me. Stop it.
> Is any of that based on life experience? Or just silliness?
If your experience proofs me wrong I'm willing to listen to what you have to say. But your post show's no content at all. SHOW US your experience! And stop the insults.
To me, your post is what you accuse me of. Silly and ramble.
And keep your thank you.
To IGDude:
IGDude, how do you want that proof delivered?
Tapes of SDH making his last girlfriend squirt?
Pictures of him with 10's everywhere?
A product recording with random girls giggling in the background?
Read some of SDH's posts and his comments to get an idea.
SDH comes from a good place, wants to help. And he is really good at it because it comes from a place of love.
At the end of the day, I have a great girlfriend now, social life is fantastic, and I lost about 35 lbs.
What did I change?
I stopped replying on guru advice and started just experimenting with my life. Taking ideas from any source, filtering out the bad stuff and discovering the good stuff.
I wrote about it here.
I know that sounds vague, but that includes trying out a couple of diets to fit my lifestyle. Giving up lots of my old PUA ideas and making my meeting-women-style super simple and natural for me.
It also includes how I ethically treat my friends.
Sometimes "my way or the highway" (steph's methods) are brilliant and really help hold your power, but other times it makes you look like an ignorant prick (unethical in a sense).
I mean seriously, who the fuck says "my way or the highway" besides an angry parent or cop... or a boyfriend trying to make a very important point.
How often are you going to say "my way or the highway"? Maybe once a year?
However that my-way-or-highway philosophy is almost the backbone of GTP---just look at how Stephane bans people for not being fully dedicated to him.
Anyway, that is all I really have to say on this.
Thanks for the unsolicited advice ;) ---notice how I'm not banning you or asking you to leave. You are free to keep posting, but I feel I have made my point.
So then thanks for not
So then thanks for not banning me^^
If I say something is bullshit- and say just that - it's pretty dull.
If I say I think this is bullshit because XYZ -and discribe my point of view- thats proof. At least I can follow your thoughts. Maybe there is a better word than proof for it but I'm not english sorry.
So don't send me pics with tens on- explain why you think what I wrote is wrong.
EVERYTHING that sdh has written is just empty. I feel he hasn't helped me at all. Good that you think so high of him, if he helped you in the past good. I don't think he's so much in the heart when he write things like that. My impression.
I went through his Blog posts. No trace of the word love, heart, feelings and stuff. He talks about methods and how to achive your goals, work hard, have a quality girlfriend. That's cool too, but not exactly loving. You get my point. I don't understand why sdh hates what I wrote.
To me 'My way or the highway' is not the core message of GTP, but thats another story.
Forget about Ideagasms for a moment. You alway put words in my mouth I haven't said. I'm NOT STEPHANE and he is not always right. So tell me what do you think about what I have written? Just what I have written. Is it wrong? What disturbes you guys on it.
It's your second reply and you have not referred to anything I wrote. I'm interested in your opinions.
Post new comment